Articles Feature

Why Some Charge Ukraine Coverage Is Racist

by richard02751

AP, Reuters Challenge WHO Leader’s Contention

Short Takes: Prince at age 11; Ricardo Zuniga; Cheryl Duvall; statehouse coverage; Narda Jones; Bakari Sellers; Catalina Camia; NPR’s “Code Switch”; ASU Cronkite School and Native American journalists; Royce Miles; James Hill; Senate Democrats and Black journalists; Dwayne Haskins; Michele Norris; USA Today’s free graphic novel on Black evictions; Chris Wallace and Nikole Hannah-Jones;

Chauncey Bailey; Lee Bey; Nicholas Casey; SPJ in Puerto Rico; disinformation in communities of color; Barack Obama; Alexandra White; Jonathan Capehart; Arnold Diaz; Corey Johnson; Maya Brown; William Monroe Trotter; Melanie Eversley; Haitian Times; Luis Patiño;

Lee Bey; El Salvador press-freedom crackdown; Mexican pair’s revelations from public records; Dalit-caste journalists; tracking attacks on African journalists; Western Sahara omitted; police assault on Cuban journalist.

Homepage photo: Ethiopia-Tigray conflict, by Human Rights Watch

(more to come)

Support Journal-isms

Days before Russian President Vladimir Putin sent troops into Ukraine, Martin Kimani, Kenyan ambassador to the United Nations, stood up at the emergency session of the U.N. Security Council to warn Russia to desist from attacking its neighbor. He attributed the world’s instability to powerful countries that assault the U.N. Charter by pursuing objectives that run counter to international peace and security. (Credit: YouTube)

AP, Reuters Challenge WHO Leader’s Contention

The director-general of the World Health Organization charged Wednesday that the news media are not treating crises around the world equally, and that racism plays a role. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus is not the first to say that, and how one reacts depends on the media one consumes, where one’s self-interest lies and one’s preconceived notions.

As Maria Cheng reported for the Associated Press, Tedros “questioned whether ‘the world really gives equal attention to Black and white lives’ – given that the ongoing emergencies in Ethiopia, Yemen, Afghanistan and Syria have garnered only a ‘fraction’ of the global concern for Ukraine.

“Tedros acknowledged the war in Ukraine is globally significant, but asked if other crises are being accorded enough attention.

“He also critiqued the media for what he said is its failure to document the ongoing atrocities in Ethiopia, noting that people had been burned alive in the region. ‘I don’t even know if that was taken seriously by the media because of their ethnicity,’ he said. ‘So we need to balance. We need to take every life seriously because every life is precious.’ ”

Tedros, who is from the war-torn Tigray section of that country, “said since a truce was declared in the besieged northern region of Ethiopia three weeks ago, about 2,000 trucks should have been able to enter with food, medicine and other essentials.

“Instead, only about 20 trucks have arrived, said Tedros, a former minister of health in Ethiopia.

“ ‘As we speak, people are dying of starvation,’ he said. ‘This is one of the longest and worst sieges by both Eritrean and Ethiopian forces in modern history.’ ”

Last month, the United Nations raised less than a third of the $4.27 billion requested for relief efforts in Yemen, according to Laurin-Whitney Gottbrath, writing March 17 for Axios, in what has been described as the world’s worst humanitarian crisis.

Gottbrath wrote Friday, “In the more than seven years since fighting between a Saudi-led coalition and the Iran-[backed] Houthi rebels began, hundreds of thousands have died of direct and indirect causes and more than 4.3 million people have been internally displaced.” Critics say the United States, which backs the Saudis, shares responsibility.

Two billion people, or a quarter of the world’s population, now live in conflict-affected areas, according to the United Nations, the most conflict since 1945, according to U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres.

Still, polls show that as much as Americans are horrified and repulsed by the Russian invasion of Ukraine, they are more concerned about pocketbook issues such as inflation.

Spokespersons for the New York Times and Washington Post did not respond to requests for comment on Tedros’ accusation.

Lauren Easton replied for the Associated Press, “I’d point you to AP’s standout coverage of Tigray.

“You might recall that AP freelancer Amir Aman Kiyaro (pictured) was detained in Ethiopia for four months for his work covering the conflict and was just released on bail on April 1. The investigation against him continues.”

Easton added: “AP continues to report on Yemen, Afghanistan and Syria, of course.

“AP won the Pulitzer Prize for International Reporting in 2019 for its Yemen civil war coverage.

“See AP Syria coverage here.

“Afghanistan. (News director Kathy Gannon and others report from inside the country. See Kathy’s latest here.”

A spokesperson for Reuters replied, “Reuters is deeply committed to covering the conflicts happening around the world and to ensuring our coverage is global. We have staff in 200 locations around the globe covering these conflicts and wider news from both a local and global perspective, including, for example, the war in Ethiopia, which has been the subject of extensive investigations by Reuters since the conflict erupted.”

Still, few would deny that the massive coverage of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, justified by the global consequences, emotional ties, news-media accessibility and the threat of nuclear war, dwarfs that of the other conflicts.

The World Food Programme says it is “the world’s largest humanitarian organization, saving lives in emergencies and using food assistance to build a pathway to peace, stability and prosperity for people recovering from conflict, disasters and the impact of climate change.” (Credit: Martine Perret/United Nations)

But is race a factor? Those who say yes maintain that that element costs the United States as well as the countries in crisis.

“I was in New York last week,” the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, Filippo Grandi, said April 11 on the “PBS NewsHour.” “I met all the African ambassadors to the United Nations. They’re very worried that this big effort to respond to the crisis in Ukraine distracts the international community from solidarity with African countries that also are hit by very, very severe humanitarian crises.”

On “Democracy Now!” Jayati Ghosh, an economics professor at the University of Massachusetts Amherst who taught for 35 years at Jawaharlal Nehru University in New Delhi, India, said Wednesday, “I don’t think people in the West realize it — is the extent to which the hypocrisy in the sort of moral double standards are evident in this Ukraine war. I mean, yes, it is terrible, what is happening. It is a brutal and completely unjustified invasion, and people are dying, and people are suffering.

“But more people have died in Yemen in the last three months, with arms provided by the U.S. and very, very brutal attacks. Children are starving in Yemen and in Afghanistan because of U.S. policy.

“And so, you know, everyone else in the world is saying, ‘How come it’s only when there are white Europeans who are affected that you care at all?’ I think the — you know, really, I don’t think people in the West realize the extent to which they have absolutely lost moral legitimacy in terms of the very, very different reaction they have exposed in this war to white European lives and all other lives in the rest of the world. This is not lost to anyone in the developing world. There is a very, very strong reaction.”

On the same program Friday, author Vijay Prashad went further. “There was an appalling bombing of the maternity hospital in Mariupol,” Ukraine. “You know, immediately thereafter, the U.S. government talked about war crimes. The International Criminal Court was suborned to say that this is going to have a file open, you know, for war crimes personally against [Russian President Vladimir] Putin and so on.

An estimated 23.4 million people — about three in four people in Yemen — need assistance, and a growing number are coping with emergency levels of hunger, according to the United Nations, which adds that 2.3 million children are acutely malnourished. Here, some are vaccinated. (Credit: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.)

“But have we forgotten the Amiriyah shelter [in Iraq], 1,500 civilians killed in 1991 when the United States bombed a shelter, knowing full well there were civilians there? No question of any interrogation of war crimes. The language of war crimes was not used in Libya after NATO quite ruthlessly bombed that country. Peter Olson of NATO, the lead attorney, said openly, ‘Look, NATO can’t commit war crimes. War crimes are committed by other people, not by NATO.’ [Olson said NATO did not deliberately target civilians].

“I mean, just this recent month, there were Israeli airstrikes which struck the Rimal medical center, two doctors killed. Do we know their names? Ayman Abu al-Auf and Moeen al-Aloul. I mean, they were killed in the middle of all this, but there was no question of calling the Israeli strikes war crimes.”

Kenya’s U.N. ambassador, Martin Kimani, won praise on Feb. 24 when he compared Russian aggression to that of Africa’s former colonial masters.

But at a March 4 webinar hosted by the U.S. Department of State in Cape Town, South Africa, African journalists were skeptical of the notion that Africa should join in the Western condemnation. “This is not our war,” a reporter from Madagascar told Molly Phee, U.S. assistant secretary of state for African Affairs.

“Africans, including myself, who have pointed out the racist hypocrisies of Western media, governments and societies evident in the response have been accused of a convenient whataboutism which blinds us to the suffering of Ukrainians,” wrote Patrick Gathara (pictured), a Nairobi-based writer and cartoonist, on March 23. “Further, others have suggested that Africans are guilty of similar hypocrisies to those they accuse the West of, seemingly more concerned about events and crises thousands of miles away but happy to ignore the many crises on their own doorstep.

“Much of this is true.”

Gathara also wrote that some Africans “seem unable to recognise that what the world looks like to a large extent depends on where one is standing. And that many here are responding not so much to the invasion itself, but rather to Western reactions to it, which have rekindled long-running grievances that much of Africa has had with the West.”

One of those grievances has been how the West covers the rest of the world, particularly Africa. In January, African organizations announced they “will put 20 leading global media platforms under the microscope to analyse how they tell Africa’s stories, whose voices are being heard, which topics are prioritised and how they are covered. The Global Media Index will also highlight best practices in reporting on the continent.”

Washington Post columnist Eugene Robinson, himself a former Post foreign editor, observed about Ukraine March 14, “Whether intentionally or subconsciously, news organizations make this war more vivid and more tragic by focusing so tightly on victims and refugees. We get to see them as individuals, not as an undifferentiated mass. Viewers and readers are invited, if not forced, to imagine ourselves in similar circumstances.”

That’s not true of Myanmar, Ethiopia, Yemen, Syria and other countries in crisis.

Britain’s Guardian editorialized March 17, aid agencies “find the multiple conflicts, the disastrous conditions in Afghanistan and what is described as the worst-ever hunger crisis in South Sudan have left them torn between grim choices.

“More humanitarian funding is needed, alongside political will and diplomatic energy. The victims of these other wars deserve the same level of support and solidarity rightly seen for the people of Ukraine. Those already too often overlooked must not be pushed further into the shadows.”

(More to come)

Short Takes

  • Narda Jones (pictured) is returning to the Federal Communications Commission as chief of staff for FCC Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel, Rosenwarcel announced April 4. Jones was director of legislative affairs for the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy. Prior to that, she was the senior technology policy adviser for the Democratic staff of the U.S. Senate Committee on Commerce, Transportation and Science. Ms. Jones started working in the United States Senate for Senator Maria Cantwell of Washington in 2014, after spending over a decade in senior roles in the Federal Communications Commission’s Wireline and International Bureaus,” the announcement said.

  • Catalina Camia has left her position as editor in chief at CQ Roll Call, Mariam Ahmed reported Sunday for Roll Call, but the veteran journalist did not disclose her next move. Camia joined CQ Roll Call in 2015 and is a former president of the Asian American Journalists Association and of Unity: Journalists of Color. Last month, Camia spoke with the National Press Foundation’s “Widening the Pipeline” fellows about how she leads a newsroom as a woman of color in the high-profile, high stakes arena of political reporting.
  • “ ‘Code Switch,’ NPR’s signature podcast on race and identity, is expanding its presence on the radio, through live and virtual events and on social media through a $600,000 grant from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting (CPB),” the corporation announced Monday. “With this two-year grant, NPR is raising the profile of the Code Switch podcast and radio program with an expansion of live and online events and the development of new offerings. With the addition of a new host and a senior editor, the Code Switch team will increase its production of short, news pieces featured on NPR’s flagship news programs, as well as longer features written and produced by influential journalists and scholars, member station contributors, and Code Switch fellows. . . .”
  • James Hill (pictured) is one of three senior editors at the Detroit Free Press who have been promoted to executive editor, Free Press Editor and Vice President Peter Bhatia announced, the newspaper said Sunday. Hill “has been at the Free Press for 22 years. Hill covered higher education, then City Hall, before moving into the editing ranks. He also has been a columnist and served on the editorial board. For the past 10 years, Hill has overseen political coverage, city and suburban news, led diversity recruiting efforts and DEI initiatives at the Free Press, coordinated the newsroom’s internship program and most recently conceived and launched Detroit Is, the Free Press’ initiative aimed at providing holistic coverage of the city. Hill was born and raised in Detroit — and is a die-hard Lions fan. He graduated from the Journalism Institute for Media Diversity at Wayne State University. . . .” Also promoted were Anjanette Delgado and Jim Schaefer.
Senate Democrats are “hoping to message . . . Black voters — through the conduit of Black journalists — about the biggest issues facing the African American community,” Alexi McCammond reported March 30 for Axios. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Shumer, D-N.Y., tweeted after the senators met with Black print, TV and radio journalists, “Your voices matter. Your reporting is indispensable. And our caucus has a responsibility to remain open, and accessible, and collaborative with all of you.” (Credit: Twitter)
  • ESPN’s Adam Schefter apologized for a tweet breaking the news of NFL quarterback Dwayne Haskins’ death, AR Shaw reported Monday for the Guardian. “Schefter caught backlash after listing Haskins’ career setbacks while reporting on his death, which occurred when the 24-year-old was hit by a truck in the early hours of Saturday morning. . . . “The sports community spoke out against Schefter’s tweet, which was posted at a time when Haskins’ family, friends, and former teammates were taking in the enormity of his death. Schefter would eventually delete the tweet, but the damage was done.”
  • “Michele Norris, a columnist for The Washington Post opinion page who from 2002 to 2012 she was a host of NPR’s “All Things Considered,” has won the 2022 Goldsmith Career Award from the Shorenstein Center on Media, Politics and Public Policy at Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government. “The music of Michele’s writing is matched by its moral power,” said Shorenstein Center Director Nancy Gibbs. “She picks up the hard questions and examines them fearlessly, in a way that has made her one of the great, wise voices of this generation.”
“Romina Ruiz-Goiriena, national housing and social services reporter for USA Today, studied thousands of eviction records with data journalist Kevin Crowe,” Sarah Scire reported April 7 for Nieman Lab. “Their analysis led them to a county in Washington state where the eviction rate for Black women is five times higher than for white renters. The resulting investigation was published as a longform article — available only to subscribers . . . But what caught my attention was the free graphic novel about eviction written by Ruiz-Goiriena and illustrated by Ariana Torrey.”
Last month, Oakland renamed the portion of 14th Street, where Chauncey Bailey, editor of the Oakland Post, was slain Aug. 2, 2007, Thomas Peele reported April 4 for EdSource. A sign now reads “Chauncey Bailey Way” “after years of pushing by his family and journalists. During a ceremony that was both tearful and joyous, much was said about the First Amendment, Bailey’s heinous murder and his lifelong commitment to public service.” (Credit: Thomas Peele/Edsource)
  • “In news first reported by Chicago media reporter Robert Feder and widely shared by former Chicago Tribune architecture critic Blair Kamin, Lee Bey (pictured), former architecture critic for the Tribune’s rival, the Chicago Sun-Times, will be returning to helm a monthly architecture column in that paper’s Sunday edition,” Matt Hickman wrote March 24 for Archpaper. “A current member of the editorial board at the Sun-Times, Chicago-born Bey is also a noted photographer and lecturer and serves as an adjunct professor at the Illinois Institute of Technology College of Architecture. . . .”

  • Nicholas Casey will be joining the New York Times Magazine as a staff writer, effective immediately,” Jake Silverstein, editor of the Magazine, announced March 2. “At the Magazine, Nick will be an international correspondent, based in Spain, and writing on a range of subjects. We got a taste of Nick’s talent for magazine longform last year in his wonderful cover story about his father, where his assured sense of narrative and beautiful writing really stood out.” Casey was Madrid bureau chief and previously covered U.S. politics, Venezuela and Colombia. 
The Society of Professional Journalists approved a chapter in Puerto Rico, President Rebecca Aguilar tweeted March 23.
“This is a 1st in @spj_tweets 112 year history,” she wrote on March 23.
  • “Former President Barack Obama is urgently throwing himself into the fight against disinformation, taking a yearslong private fascination into the open as he makes addressing the issue a key pillar of his post-presidency,” Dan Merica and Donie O’Sullivan reported Sunday or CNN. They also wrote, “Obama’s effort has been sweeping, say the former President’s confidants and outside advisers with experience in the tech industry, with Obama convening meetings and conversations with academics, activists, researchers, tech sector leaders, media executives, former government officials and former regulators. . . .”
  • The Washington Post has promoted Pulitzer Prize-winning opinion writer Jonathan Capehart (pictured) to associate editor. “The promotion is a reflection of Jonathan’s leadership at The Post where he has been a pivotal voice since 2007, both through his role on The Post’s editorial board and his weekly column exploring the intersection of social, cultural and political issues,” the March 30 announcement said. “Capehart hosts a weekly Opinions podcast, ‘Capehart,’ formerly named ‘Cape Up,’ and the weekly Washington Post Live show ‘First Look,’ which streams on Peacock, NBCUniversal’s streaming service. Capehart is also the host of ‘The Sunday Show with Jonathan Capehart,’ which airs Sundays 10:00 a.m. – 12:00 p.m. ET on MSNBC. In addition, he serves as a political analyst on ‘PBS NewsHour’ and is featured on the popular Friday segment, ‘Brooks and Capehart. ‘ . . .”
  • “Arnold Diaz (pictured), investigative reporter at WPIX New York, has retired,” Michael Malone reported April 6 for nexttv.com. “Diaz has been on TV for 50 years. His investigative franchise on WPIX is called ‘What a Shame!’ and ‘regularly exposes wrongdoing and incompetence by private industry and government agencies, and often leads to actions by law enforcement officials, as well as the enactment of legislation.’ ”
  • Corey Johnson (pictured) is joining ProPublica from the Tampa Bay Times, where he worked for five years as an investigative reporter, ProPublica announced Tuesday. “His project ‘Poisoned’ revealed how Florida’s only lead smelter endangered hundreds of workers and polluted the surrounding community. . . .” The organization also hired Andy Kroll, Washington bureau chief for Rolling Stone, and Brett Murphy of USA Today.
  • To commemorate what would have been activist Boston publisher William Monroe Trotter’s (pictured)150th birthday, the Rev. Cornell Brooks, the founder of the William Monroe Trotter Collaborative for Social Justice at Harvard University, held a symposium April 7 and 8 to honor his legacy, Tori Bedford reported in a podcast April 7 for WGBH radio, known as GBH News.
  • “In a study conducted by Fundamedios with support from the Donald W. Reynolds Journalism Institute Fellowship, the organization interviewed 115 journalists and looked at pay studies from several newsrooms. ‘The most common claim expressed was about differences in their working conditions or contracts,” Stephanie Casanova wrote April 5 for the Women’s Media Center. The headline was, “The Low-Balling of Spanish-Language Reporters.” “Latino journalists do the same job as their white peers with fewer resources, and less pay,’ the study found. . . .”
  • “I have just written my last story for the Wall Street Journal,” Lee Hawkins (pictured) wrote March 25 on LinkedIn. “It is a Page One story about the ongoing debate that has resulted from the reality that the Jesuits used the profits from slavery to found Georgetown University and dozens of other Catholic colleges and high schools. Kudos to my co-writer and colleague, Doug Belkin, for a great job. It’s been a great 19-year journey. I will miss my colleagues and friends. In the coming weeks, we will be excited to announce my next venture: a foray into the podcasting world, where I will be doing more around the subjects of race and equity in America. I will also be speaking ahead of the release my forthcoming book, NOBODY’S SLAVE: How Uncovering My Family’s History Set Me Free (HarperCollins 2023).”
  • “El Salvadoran journalists are raising the alarm over a new law that could imprison journalists for 10 to 15 years,” Foreign Press Correspondents USA reported Tuesday. “The country’s congress has authorized harsh prison sentences for news media that reproduce or disseminate messages from gangs, playing into President Nayib Bukele’s long-standing war with press freedoms in the country. A flurry of gang killings in late March prompted Bukele to seek out and win emergency powers, which resulted in the arrests and detainment of some 6,000 people and the penning of the new legislation.”
Dardo Neubauer and Laura Sánchez Ley
  • In Mexico, journalists Dardo Neubauer and Laura Sánchez Ley launched Archivero (which means “archivist”) last month, Hanaa’ Tameez wrote Monday for Nieman Lab. “They request public records to have them declassified and reveal information that the government kept secret. Their goal is to add context and follow up on current stories in the news and unsolved cases, and to find threads for future stories. Archivero’s work is currently free to access. Sánchez and Neubauer are a team of two and neither of them works on Archivero full-time. They’re funding the project themselves, though they offer paid research and consulting services. They also offer workshops and trainings on Mexico’s transparency laws and the United States’ Freedom of Information Act. . . .”
  • “Journalists who come from minority backgrounds often face multiple challenges at work and in their personal life,” Ruby Winter wrote for the April issue of Toxic Avenger magazine. “From their gender identity to their race, their religious expression to their opinions about social issues – all of them are used by trolls to target them online and off. One of these vulnerable circles are journalists who belong to the Dalit caste, originating in South Asia. In this age-old system, a person is assigned a caste at the time of their birth and this limits every aspect of their life from what jobs they can pursue to whom they can marry. . . . As April is Dalit History Month, we spoke to Thenmozhi Soundararajan (pictured), executive director of Equality Labs – an organization dedicated to fighting for the civil rights of Dalits and her team to get insight into the experiences of Dalit reporters. . . . “
  • “Israeli officials recently hosted representatives of Morocco, Egypt, Bahrain and the United Arab Emirates,” Ari Paul reported April 5 for Fairness & Accuracy In Reporting. “For US media, this meant many things, but one thing that didn’t make the papers was that Israel and Morocco share a common goal: maintaining military occupations that are widely condemned throughout the world. . . . What was missing from most of the reports on this subject — or in some cases buried — is Morocco’s ongoing occupation of the Western Sahara region.”
  • “Cuban authorities should thoroughly investigate the recent attack on journalist Alberto Corzo (pictured) and swiftly bring those responsible to justice,” the Committee to Protect Journalists said April 8. “On April 1, at approximately 10 a.m., two agents from the Department of State Security, commonly referred to as the political police, stopped Corzo in the street in the Colón municipality in the western Matanzas province, and demanded to know where he was headed and what he was doing, Corzo said in a video statement published by the Cuban Institute for Freedom of Expression and of the Press (ICLEP), a press freedom organization which also publishes and distributes seven community newspapers in Cuba. Corzo is ICLEP’s executive director. . . Cuban authorities have repeatedly targeted ICLEP journalists and outlets with various forms of harassment in retaliation for their independent reporting, including raids, detentions, and other forms of coercion. Corzo has been previously targeted with several intimidation tactics by Cuban authorities, including being arrested and interrogated, as documented by CPJ.” (Photo credit: ICLEP)

 ‘ Support Journal-isms

 

To subscribe at no cost, please send an email to journal-isms+subscribe@groups.io and say who you are.

Facebook users: “Like” “Richard Prince’s Journal-isms” on Facebook.

Follow Richard Prince on Twitter @princeeditor

Richard Prince’s Journal-isms originates from Washington. It began in print before most of us knew what the internet was, and it would like to be referred to as a “column.” Any views expressed in the column are those of the person or organization quoted and not those of any other entity. Send tips, comments and concerns to Richard Prince at journal-isms+owner@groups.io

About Richard Prince

View previous columns (after Feb. 13, 2016).

View previous columns (before Feb. 13, 2016)

 

Related posts

Public TV Viewers Browner Than You Think

richard

NAJA Votes Name Change to ‘Indigenous’

richard

Dems Flaunted Diversity, but to What End?

richard

Leave a Comment

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.